About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

Ransomware: Should You Pay or Should You Go?

By Jolley | Hadaway | Wednesday, May 3, 2017 - Leave a Comment

Avoiding “The Clash” with Management!


A Jolley | Hadaway article review.


ServIcons_ITAudit_01

There are three things very unique about ransomware:  First, from a containment perspective, it’s a bit different than normal malware.  Second, from a response perspective, the way you handle forensics with ransomware may need to conform to a different set of standards than normal.  Finally, from a recovery perspective, it’s the only malware attack vector . . . so far . . . that management will want to weigh in on during the recovery phase of response.

And when it comes to paying a ransomware demand, there’s no one-size-fits-all policy…

Sometimes, it’s hard to know what’s increasing faster, the number of cases of ransomware infections or the number of articles about those infections! Indeed, we’ve written about the subject several times ourselves, and for good reason: a Malwarebytes-sponsored survey from 2016 showed 40% of polled businesses had experienced at least one such attack, with a third of those victims having lost revenue as a result. A similar study, sponsored by Carbonite, showed 51% of businesses had been struck.

With numbers like that, it is surprising that according to the same Carbonite-sponsored study less than half of the respondents (46%) believed preparation for a ransomware attack was a “high priority” within their organizations. This is especially troubling since ransomware attacks almost universally come with a deadline attached, leaving incident response teams precious little time to determine the best course of action even WITH a policy in place.

Complicating matters further is that there are conflicting opinions on what that course of action should be. Europol, the FBI and independent security researchers such as Brian Krebs are adamant about not paying, citing concerns about supporting criminal activities along with the fact that paying a ransom is no guarantee you’ll get your data back: a Trend Micro study cited by ZDNet suggests as many as one-in-five businesses will get fleeced in this manner.

Despite the stern warnings from experts, though, some estimates put the number of businesses that eventually pay their attackers at more than 40 percent, with some stating a ransom was paid even when the organization had backups! For some, giving in is simply the cheapest option.

Due to the uncertainty surrounding each individual attack, it can be difficult to come up with a realistic policy regarding them–the value of the data at stake, the ransomware itself and the temperament of the organization’s leadership can all play a role in the decision.

That’s why in coming up with our own official policy we’ve considered not expressing personal opinions to impacted customers during an active infection, choosing to provide them with information detailing the pros and cons to payment–information like this article review.

Similarly, when it comes to implementing policy before an attack we believe being realistic and flexible is a must: Mandating a rigid “no payment” policy can create issues as we have seen executives who insist on paying out as the cheapest, quickest option to get back in business.

So, in the words of Mike Jones from The Clash*, as an ISO, you may have to say this in your next committee meeting:  “this indecision’s bugging me, if you don’t want to, set me free, should I stay or should I go now?”

Because of the unique nature of ransomware, many institutions are finding it prudent to document the response scenario surrounding ransomware as a different attack scenario than normal malware.  Regardless of the path you choose to take, the most important thing is to start work now, before an attack, so that you’re not starting from scratch as the clock runs out. When researching these articles, we were surprised to find there are not a lot of starting points available, from a policy/procedure perspective.  So we went to work on our own ransomware document, that would be subset to a Virus Incident Response Scenario document if you’re team requires it.To help you get started we’ve decided to give away our ransomware policy boilerplate document fo

To help you get started we’ve decided to give away our ransomware policy boilerplate document for free!  You can download a copy of this free policy boilerplate through our online store.  Keep in mind this is our first iteration.  Just use the promo code, “theclashcode“.   You may use this code for both the standalone ransomware scenario document, as well as the virus incident response scenario document. You can check out one at a time or add both, the code will work either way.

Standalone Ransomware Scenario Document
Price: $20.00

 

Virus Incident Response Scenario Document
Price: $20.00

PROMO CODE: theclashcode

Note that the standalone ransomware document is a subset of the virus incident response document.  

To summarize:  it’s time to start researching ransomware and adding it to your incident response documents, as a separate attack vector because it has unique characteristics.

*Catchy subtitle by Michael Hartke.

Article by Matt Jolley and Dan Hadaway.

same_strip_012513


 

Latest News
    Employees working from home may find it more difficult to follow security policies… An article review. The surge in employees working from home during the pandemic created many headaches for IT departments around the world, many of whom had no telecommuting policies or procedures before the start… but what about the employees who had to […]
    A Webinar-Movie infotex presents the 2021 update of a previously released webinar presented by our Lead Non-Technical Auditor, Adam Reynolds. This movie-short is intended for those who are planning to participate in an infotex Incident Response Test. Not sure about the importance of an Incident Response Test? Check out onetest.infotex.com for more information! Please let […]
    PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE BUSINESS NEWS INFOTEX PROMOTES BRYAN BONNELL TO DIGITAL MEDIA MANAGER infotex, the Managed Security Service Provider, announced Bryan Bonnell’s promotion from Senior Data Security Analyst to Digital Media Manager.  “He will continue his normal DSA duties on a limited basis, because we want everybody to stay in touch with […]
    PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE BUSINESS NEWS RYAN HENSLER OF INFOTEX, EARNS CISSP CERTIFICATE Ryan Hensler, Senior NOC Associate of infotex, Inc., recently received the CISSP certification. “Ryan has proven himself to be a seasoned security professional both in his work for infotex and now through achieving this certification.” said Sean Waugh, Information Security Officer. […]
    Dubious app store subscriptions bring in hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue… An article review. When it comes to malicious applications you’re probably familiar with things like malware and ransomware, and you have ways to avoid them.  Modern desktop and smartphone operating systems have built-in malware detection tools, and some web browsers even automatically […]
    Another Manifesto A supply-chain manifesto by the author of Never Say Never: A Password Manifesto! Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . [Sssshh.  Turn out the lights.  Let’s lower our inner voices, as I have something to propose that might be a bit […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office.  
    While malware and security exploits continue to make headlines, the majority of reported security incidents involve phishing… An article review. With all the attention given recently to security incidents involving software exploits and high-profile malware attacks, it would be easy to believe that they represented the most likely incidents you may encounter in the wild.  […]
    Implementing Protective DNS could help your organization avoid attack… An article review. Noting the risks still associated with the Domain Name System (DNS), the National Security Agency and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) have recently released new guidance on the selection and use of a Protective DNS service (PDNS). The guidance, released in […]
    A Webinar-Movie In 2018 the NCUA started reviewing credit unions with $1 billion or more in assets using a tool known as the Automated Cybersecurity Examination Tool, or ACET. The expansion to smaller credit unions is inevitable. In the new year, credit unions should now think about how they can come into compliance with the […]