About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

With Windows Hello, Users May Be Trading Security For Convenience

By Jolley | Hadaway | Tuesday, September 13, 2016 - Leave a Comment

 


Microsoft promises ‘enterprise-grade’ security without a password, so what’s the catch?


puzzle smallerWhen Windows 10 was launched there was a great deal of attention paid to some of its more controversial aspects, such as the inability for end users to disable updates.  (We kind of liked that one).  But we didn’t like the operating system’s collection and transmission of user data!

While the controversy kept our attention, other new features were added with little fanfare. Such is the case with Windows Hello, an entirely new method for logging into Windows devices which Microsoft began rolling out with the Windows 10 “Anniversary Update” in July.

Windows Hello, as Microsoft describes on their site, is said to bring ‘enterprise-grade’ security to both home and business users alike.  If that wasn’t enough, it promises to do so while also eliminating the password entirely! Whenever a vendor makes promises about security that sound too good to be true, we’re always dubious.  And when Dan acquired his shiny new Surface Pro, our suspicions were confirmed: without proper configuration, Windows Hello can make a system less secure!

The issue lies with Windows Hello’s PIN usage, which is to be a backup for when Window’s Hello fails.  If you’re using it’s slick biometrics feature (either fingerprint or facial recognition) and for some reason the biometrics fails, you can use a PIN to log in.  Or when the users Windows Hello “companion device” such as a Microsoft Band or Windows Phone is unavailable, you can use a PIN to log in.

When either of these login methods fails, Windows Hello falls back on a simple PIN the user creates when setting up the system for the first time–and it may be as short as four digits!

The end result is that we were able to easily gain access to other accounts on our Surface Pro simply by failing the facial recognition and guessing their four digit PIN! Not only is this hardly ‘enterprise-grade’ security, Microsoft goes on to assert this method is more secure than logging in with a Microsoft account because the latter requires the transmission of the (encrypted) account password over the internet, while the PIN is locally authenticated.

But it’s only four digits.  We tried to use a strong password BUT THAT IS NOT ALLOWED.  (You can use longer pins though).

We think that a four digit number is not adequate security . . . locally authenticated or not . . .  and that, for the moment, it is advisable to continue using a local account or a Microsoft Account if security is important to you. If you do want to keep using Windows Hello, it’s advisable that you use a longer PIN, and one that is not shared with any other accounts.

In that last paragraph we said “for the moment” because while home users are limited to numeric PINs, enterprise editions of Windows 10 have the option to enable complex PINs consisting of letters and numbers (which makes ‘PIN’ a misnomer) and Microsoft could roll out an update granting this privilege to home users at a future date.

Why Microsoft thinks this option is something only large companies would want is just one of the questions surrounding the new operating system, but it’s one we wish they would answer–sooner rather than later.  Now, because we don’t want to hurt Microsoft’s feelings, we do think this methodology offers a lot of potential.  We’re hoping they leverage this infrastructure for true two factor authentication (your face and your pin) into the endpoint.  But for now, if you don’t acquire the enterprise edition, it’s weak single factor authentication.

We want you to avoid having a false sense of security.  Sorry Microsoft, you’re heading in the right direction, but Windows Hello is NOT more secure.

Article by Matt Jolley and Dan Hadaway


same_strip_012513


 

Latest News
    As the investigation of the SolarWinds Hack was ongoing, another hack stole some of the limelight… This is the final update on the SolarWinds hack unless a major development comes to light. You can see the previous article here: “Autopsy of the SolarWinds Hack Update“. One of the largest cyber-espionage campaigns in the history of […]
    Employees working from home may find it more difficult to follow security policies… An article review. The surge in employees working from home during the pandemic created many headaches for IT departments around the world, many of whom had no telecommuting policies or procedures before the start… but what about the employees who had to […]
    A Webinar-Movie infotex presents the 2021 update of a previously released webinar presented by our Lead Non-Technical Auditor, Adam Reynolds. This movie-short is intended for those who are planning to participate in an infotex Incident Response Test. Not sure about the importance of an Incident Response Test? Check out onetest.infotex.com for more information! Please let […]
    PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE BUSINESS NEWS INFOTEX PROMOTES BRYAN BONNELL TO DIGITAL MEDIA MANAGER infotex, the Managed Security Service Provider, announced Bryan Bonnell’s promotion from Senior Data Security Analyst to Digital Media Manager.  “He will continue his normal DSA duties on a limited basis, because we want everybody to stay in touch with […]
    PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE BUSINESS NEWS RYAN HENSLER OF INFOTEX, EARNS CISSP CERTIFICATE Ryan Hensler, Senior NOC Associate of infotex, Inc., recently received the CISSP certification. “Ryan has proven himself to be a seasoned security professional both in his work for infotex and now through achieving this certification.” said Sean Waugh, Information Security Officer. […]
    Dubious app store subscriptions bring in hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue… An article review. When it comes to malicious applications you’re probably familiar with things like malware and ransomware, and you have ways to avoid them.  Modern desktop and smartphone operating systems have built-in malware detection tools, and some web browsers even automatically […]
    Another Manifesto A supply-chain manifesto by the author of Never Say Never: A Password Manifesto! Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . [Sssshh.  Turn out the lights.  Let’s lower our inner voices, as I have something to propose that might be a bit […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office.  
    While malware and security exploits continue to make headlines, the majority of reported security incidents involve phishing… An article review. With all the attention given recently to security incidents involving software exploits and high-profile malware attacks, it would be easy to believe that they represented the most likely incidents you may encounter in the wild.  […]
    Implementing Protective DNS could help your organization avoid attack… An article review. Noting the risks still associated with the Domain Name System (DNS), the National Security Agency and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) have recently released new guidance on the selection and use of a Protective DNS service (PDNS). The guidance, released in […]