About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

Wisdom and Advice for Incident Response Testing

By Dan Hadaway | Thursday, June 25, 2015 - Leave a Comment

Testing Reduced to Two Bullet Lists!

How to make sure your Incident Response Tests are “amenable” to your auditors!
Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . .



One of my favorite Clients is preparing for his or her (when she gave me permission to turn my answer into an article, she made it clear she didn’t want to be known) Incident Response Test scheduled for July.  She e-mailed me the following question:

“I’m preparing for our Incident Response Test.  I’m planning on doing two scenarios.  First being the loss of a bank owned cell phone and the second the loss of an employee owned cell phone.  Any words of wisdom or advice?”

To which I, a person with both wisdom and advice, replied as follows:

Words of wisdom:

  • Be sure you hold a “Walk-through Test” in advance of the tabletop test.
  • Be sure you have three documents as the paper-trail of the test process:
    1. The Test Plan (that is reviewed with the IRT prior to the actual test date.  Could be during the walk-through.)
      • The test plan should lay out the overall test scenario (in your case, Mobile Device Breach), but not give the team the heads-up on the “sub-scenarios.”
      • It should spell out all the requirements of the test.
    2. Minutes from the actual test.
    3. Documentation of a “Post-Mortem Review” that includes action items, if possible.  It could include planned changes to the plan.  NIST calls this the Post-Incident Follow-up Document.
  • Be sure that one of the “sub-scenarios” would be classified as a “disclosure incident” or however your policy is set up to require you to notify your customers.  You want your team to know what it feels like to have to make that decision.
  • Make the last sub-scenarios be an incident that occurs when everybody who is participating in the other sub-scenarios are not available.


  • In my experience, a quick two hour meeting is not enough.  Consider making it a four hour test, separated by lunch.  10-12, 1-3.
  • Test as many sub-scenarios as time allows.
  • Try to fit a “black swan sub-scenario” into the day . . . . an event that has a low likelihood but huge impact.  So in the case of the mobile device plans you have, maybe we discover that the employee had “temporarily” e-mailed a huge spreadsheet with thousands of ssns, names, addresses, account numbers, the works) to himself, and actually had the file up on his cell phone before he saw the geeky looking guy run off with it screaming “I can get $90 a record for this baby!”
  • Or something like that.


Original article by Dan Hadaway CRISC CISA CISM. Founder and Managing Partner, infotex

“Dan’s New Leaf” is a “fun blog to inspire thought in the area of IT Governance.”




Latest News
    A Webinar-Movie In 2018 the NCUA started reviewing credit unions with $1 billion or more in assets using a tool known as the Automated Cybersecurity Examination Tool, or ACET. The expansion to smaller credit unions is inevitable. In the new year, credit unions should now think about how they can come into compliance with the […]
    What are the top seven risks your board should know about in 2021? Since his first board presentation in 2000, when Dan presents audit reports to boards of directors, he also talks to the board about the top risks the institution is facing. Since 2006, Dan has been compiling a list of the “top seven […]
    It’s time for another workshop for the technical side of the community-bank. The infotex Team brings you all new topics for 2021! Topics that are jam packed with all the techno-babble that is often lost on management, but is music to the Bank IT Geek’s ears. Time for a workshop where we can turn off the […]
     A Timeline Update as of 02/22/21 An update to our Newest Employee’s FIRST Technical Article Another interim post-mortem review . . . . A Note About Updates: We have decided to leave the original article as it was originally posted and to update this post with any changes that have been made. You can see […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office.  
    A Webinar-Movie The 2020 annual webinar update on the subject will include a review of the previous years’ movies that are already available, and a discussion about alternative tactics that have arisen from recent virtual conferences and regulator panels.
    The cybersecurity industry faces challenges, and some of them may involve your business… An article review. In a world where threats to your organization’s electronic assets are constantly emerging and evolving a cybersecurity insurance policy can help mitigate risk…but what kind of risk does the cybersecurity insurance industry face?  A new article in the Harvard […]
    A Timeline as of 01/24/2021 Our Newest Employee’s FIRST Technical Article Another interim post-mortem review . . . . A Note About Updates: We are leaving this article as is, but for any updates to the timeline, check the Autopsy of the SolarWinds Hack Timeline Update article!      – Vigilize Introduction: As the managing […]
    PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE BUSINESS NEWS FORUM AND CONFERENCE NEWS infotex is proud to announce that Dan Hadaway will be moderating a series of IT Forums for the Ohio Bankers League. “We are excited to continue fostering the relationship with the OBL to help educate and keep Risk Management at the forefront of […]
    Top 7 Trend Articles of 2021. . .  . . .For ISOs of Small Financial Institutions. Welcome to our annual T7 article:  a list of our favorite trend articles from the past year.  Our intent: help you organize your thoughts as your work through your strategic planning process.  We hope reviewing these articles will help you […]