About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

The Value of Information Debated!

By Dan Hadaway | Saturday, February 7, 2015 - Leave a Comment

One takeaway of the Anthem Breach . . .


But not the main takeaway!
Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . .


ServIcons_ITAudit_01

I’m writing a different article about the main takeaway of the Anthem Breach (that what caused it was a false sense of security.)

But I am intrigued about a debate arising because of a claim by one of the “New Information Security Experts” (see trend #5 of my article, M-7 2015.)  But what makes the chatter of the talking heads even more fun, and enheartening, is watching them debate the value of information.

We got to see one of the experts, Katherine Keefe, global focus group leader for breach response services at Beazley, which underwrites cyberliability policies, claim that “The value to a criminal of having a full set of medical information on a person can go for $40 to $50 on the street. By contrast, a credit card number is often worth $4 or $5.”

Now I’m not going to argue what the current value of a medical file is, and I’m sure Ms. Keefe did not mean to simplify it that much.  And it is MUCH easier to contain the impact of a compromised authentication device than an entire identity.  But I’m loving that the conversation is taking place, and that the talking heads are figuring this out!

I’m sure Katherine has a basis for her claim, but identity information is a commodity and its price is situational.  (Hillary Clinton’s medical file is worth more than $50, and if a bad guy found Bill Gates’ credit card, he’d probably use it and not sell it for $5.  We’ve also seen complete sets of financial information go for $90 each.  And who knows, maybe thanks to Anthem and others the value of pii as a commodity is depressed, due to an unexpected over abundance of supply!)

What I like about the current chatter is that part of the silly sucking sound we’re hearing . . . . the noise made when thousands of executives pull their heads out of the sand simultaneously (yes, I’m using alliteration here!) . . . . is the sound of these same executives realizing that information TRULY DOES HAVE VALUE.  And we can see the talking heads realizing that there is such a thing as Personally Identifiable Information, and that people can use very small bits of information to do rather large things.

And that . . . . to me . . . . is what the beginning of the end sounds like!

In other words, we are going to see a Consolidation of Quality in the next ten years, because IT Governance has finally taken a seat next to Customer Service and maybe even Accounting in the halls of the Popular Business Processes.  Yes, customer service is important.  But so is the value of information.


Original article by Dan Hadaway CRISC CISA CISM. Founder and Managing Partner, infotex

“Dan’s New Leaf” is a “fun blog to inspire thought in the area of IT Governance.”

 


same_strip_012513


 

Latest News
    The Four Basic Truths of System Security Webinar-Video The last thirty years have seen an evolution of frameworks, laws, and assessment approaches to information security which can intimidate the management team with their complexity. This webinar will discuss the four basic truths of system security regardless of frameworks or approach, and eight control systems to […]
    Community Banking and their layers of security. . . Michael Hartke’s first post as Executive Vice President! Thinking back to my first talk to security professionals in community banking almost 10 years ago, the question continues to this day. First some background… infotex was moderating the Indiana Bankers Association Security Conference when one of the […]
    Reasons why we should be considered! infotex provides a number of services that can be checked out if you click over to offerings.infotex.com! We even made a movie with all the reasons why infotex should be your next MSOC!  
    infotex and GoTo To all infotex managed security service Clients: As recently reported by major news outlets there was a data breach affecting GoTo (formerly LogMeIn) wherein attackers stole encrypted backups containing customer information in November 2022.  Based on the advisory from GoTo the products they offer that are affected include LogMeIn Pro, LogMeIn Central, […]
    An option for increasing security for ALL organizations. . . The threat landscape is evolving daily, and it is becoming increasingly difficult for even large organizations providing cyber defense services to keep up. As Brandao (2021) notes, it is important for organizations to adapt holistic technologies that can correlate all attack events. Therefore, developing XDR […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Check out posters.infotex.com for the whole collection! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape) You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your […]
    A relic of the internet’s less secure past, many small firms struggle to secure their email systems… An article review. With a great deal of cybersecurity related news focused on new threats and similarly new techniques aimed at combating them, it can be easy to forget some of the older threats that have never gone […]
    Seven Trends . . . …that small bank Information Security Officers face in 2023 Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . Welcome to the Magnificent Seven, my annual predictive article about the seven trends in technology that will impact the Information Security Officers of […]
    System Security and Cybersecurity are not the same thing. . . Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . Regarding “information security,” the last thirty years have seen an evolution of frameworks, laws, and assessment approaches which intimidate the management team with their complexity.  […]
    The cryptographic algorithm is vulnerable to attack and is no longer considered secure… An article review. NIST has announced that it plans to retire the SHA-1 cryptographic algorithm by the end of 2030, citing multiple vulnerabilities in the standard, effectively ending its use after nearly 30 years.  Introduced in 1995, SHA-1 used a 160-bit hash […]