About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

Risk-Based Authentication Practices

By Dan Hadaway | Monday, June 21, 2021 - Leave a Comment

A follow-up on Dan’s 2008 Password Manifesto


On the NIST Publication on Digital Identity Guidelines
Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . .


In June 2017, NIST released a special publication on digital identity, NIST SP 800-63, that is starting to get the attention of our larger Clients.  We believe this is due in-part because some in management want to use the guidance to justify weaker authentication controls.  I posit this because one of the questions I received about this actually pointed to the recommendation to use 8-character passwords on low-risk systems.

Now, I still maintain it’s easier to type a 20-character sentence than an 8-character strong password, but putting that aside, I guess I can see weaker requirements on low-risk systems as okay.  But why confuse the heck out of users??  And who has low-risk systems?

But again, let’s put that to the side and talk about real-world uses of a risk-based approach to authentication.

While I admit I didn’t read the entire thing yet (it’s 100+ pages), I do like the notion of taking a “risk-based approach” to authentication.  The NIST publication appears to define 3 specific levels of ‘authentication assurance’.  Similar to how the CAT now requires us to perform a criticality analysis so we know where to focus our monitoring controls, this guidance defines acceptable authentication requirements for 3 levels of asset sensitivities.  They are called Authenticator Assurance Levels, (AAL), where

  • AAL1 is for low-risk
  • AAL2 is for moderate-risk
  • AAL3 is for high-risk

It defines permitted authentication types (AAL1 is anything from just a memorized password to multi-factor cryptographic device whereas AAL3 only allows multi-factor methods), how often re-authentication should be required, and other standards.

In terms of how regulators are implementing it, the auditors at infotex have NOT seen anything referencing these new guidelines in our audits, to-date.  Still, since this guidance is relatively new, something will most likely be coming especially for banks over 5 billion.

Be sure to note that the NIST guidelines explicitly state they don’t take into account physical access controls.  Additionally, when adding additional authentication factors like biometrics, the need for excessively long and overly complex passwords does reduce a bit (but not entirely).  Similar to how we’ve seen guidance change on frequency of password expiration/changes . . . the reason a risk-based approach is great is because it will allow us to base strategy on how people actually use these authentication systems.  By requiring unique, excessively long, and complex passwords that are changed too frequently, we may inadvertently be encouraging bad practices like using easily identifiable words and information since users have no other way to keep all these credentials memorized.

For resources, I direct you to my original article on password aging from long before Microsoft finally agreed it was an outdated control:  https://my.infotex.com/manifesto/

And, if you haven’t thought to use it, consider sharing this oft reference XKCD comic with your management team, it helps explain how password complexity is sometimes a misnomer in terms of actual strength of passwords:  https://xkcd.com/936/


Original article by Dan Hadaway CRISC CISA CISM. Founder and Managing Partner, infotex

“Dan’s New Leaf” is a “fun blog to inspire thought in the area of IT Governance.”

 


same_strip_012513


 

Latest News
    Thanks for being interested in our Technology Planning Webinars! This year‘s annual update to our annual Technology Planning webinar will include a panel discussion, a review of the previous years’ movies that are already available, and a discussion about alternative tactics that have arisen from recent conferences as well as the impact of the AIO […]
    Welcome Cybersecurity Conference Attendees! Thanks for joining us for the Cybersecurity Conference today! We have created this page for you to have access to the deliverables from Dan’s talk.  
    What you need to know for compliance coast-to-coast. Back in 2020 we posted an article containing links to data breach laws from each state, and it has proven to be one of our more popular posts.  Because laws surrounding the use (and abuse) of technology are always evolving, we thought it was worth taking another […]
    Why It Rhymes With SEEM (And its Not the I Before E Rule) Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . It’s the Gestalt. The idea that the whole is greater than the sum of it’s parts. That’s not something that is often brought […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office. Interested in one of ours […]
    Questions about China’s new disclosure laws only highlight the uncertainty about disclosure in general… An article review. China recently made waves in the security world by announcing a new set of data security laws, one of which has added new fuel to a long running debate: how and when should security vulnerabilities be disclosed…and to […]
    Four Conditions … …For Why a Network Can be Anything But a Network! Another one of those Dan’s New Leaf Posts, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . I have to admit that infotex is being called into engineering meetings with larger organizations these days that are NOT community based banks.  We […]
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office. Interested in one of ours […]
    If Zero days need Zero clicks, are there any secure devices in the mix? Tanvee Dhir explores the Pegasus spyware. Another technical post, meant to inspire thought about IT Governance . . . . Introduction Over the past couple of weeks, we have seen multiple stories regarding a powerful piece of spyware called Pegasus sold […]