About Us | Contact Us
View Cart

Shredding: New and Old Risks

By Dan Hadaway | Saturday, December 10, 2011 - Leave a Comment

In these days of drill-down risk assessments on new technologies and issues ranging from mobile banking to customer awareness to social media to FILs and Supplements, I’m often asked: “Since we now have to track these risk assessment triggers do we need to continue the annual risk assessment?”

The answer is yes.

This can be illustrated by an interesting article my friend Joe Cychosz just liked on his Facebook page.

Elizabeth Montalbano of InformationWeek reports about a challenge held by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) to solve complex puzzles comprised of shredded documents.   Somebody rose to the challenge, and using math and computers, reconstructed five documents that had been shredded into 10,000 pieces.  They won $50,000.

In other words, shredding as a control just grew weaker.

Now I agree that the likelihood of somebody spending 600 hours manually trying out pattern combinations generated by complex computer programs on shredded documents stolen from your shred-company is very low.

But this article makes an interesting way to put out that:

1)    The controls we “declare” this year may not work as strong next year.  Bad guys learn ways around them.  Good guys forget about them.

2)    The likelihood of an attack this year may not be as low next year.  New attack methods can increase the likelihood of an attack.

3)    The value of a target (and thus the likelihood of an attack) can change over time.  If somebody can bottle the process up so that it only takes 20 hours to assemble the most likely permutations of shred pattern matches, it might be worth reassembling a report with a thousand names.  What was typically a worthless target (shreddings) may increase in value.

4)    Finally, the impact of an attack can change over time.  If a breach occurs today because somebody spent 600 hours reassembling a critical report, I don’t think it will hurt anybody reputationally.  It might even give them the ability to turn the situation into good press.  But ten years from now, you have to wonder if “algorhythm proof shredders” will be a high-risk issue on everybody’s audit checklists.

So yes, we need to dust off the “All-encompassing Ever-Growing Information Technology Risk Assessment” every year, taking a quick look at all asset-vulnerability pairs that were deemed “moderate/low” last year.


Founder and President, Infotex


“Dan’s New Leaf” is a “fun blog to inspire thought in the area of IT Governance.”



Latest News
    Ransomware payments sent to countries under sanctions could result in fines… An article review. Whether or not to pay the organization behind a ransomware attack has been a hotly debated subject for many years, but a new advisory issued by the Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) warns those who do pay up […]
    Welcome Webinar Attendees! You can download the deliverables by clicking on the link below. Boilerplates/Handouts Click here to download files.        
    Another awareness poster for YOUR customers (and users).  Now that we have our own employees aware, maybe it’s time to start posting content for our customers! Download the large versions here: Awareness Poster (Portrait) Awareness Poster (Landscape)   You are welcome to print out and distribute this around your office. Data by Rob Sobers, writing […]
    Thanks for being interested in our Technology Planning Webinars! This year‘s annual webinar on the subject will include a review of the previous years’ movies that are already available, and a discussion about alternative tactics that have arisen from recent virtual conferences and regulator panels. It’s not too late to register for the 2020 Technology […]
    Check out the Sponsor Video! We will be updating the video on YouTube in the coming days, but will include the credits so everyone is recognized for all their hard work. Like our Facebook, Twitter, and Subscribe on YouTube for further updates! Credits Producer: Bryan Bonnell “K0s$” Director: Sara Fultz Editor: Sofia Tafoya Wardrobe: Our […]